Thursday Gourmet — Popovers

25 June, 2009

My mother grew up in the Boston area.  One of her family dishes, a good New England dish (though I’ve also read that they are popular in, of all places, Arkansas) — popovers.    One day, my mom announced that she would be making this family specialty.  She had made them before, when we lived at Death Valley, and I vaguely remembered how good they were. 

She neglected to consider that we were no longer living at sea level (Death Valley) but were now about 7,000 feet (2100 metres) above sea level — Grand Canyon, Arizona.  That meant, of course, high altitude recipes for cookies, cakes, even boiled eggs and pasta (water boils at a lower temperature, so things cook more slowly).  Popovers depend upon expanding steam to give them loft.  At high altitude?  Hockey pucks.  No air bubbles at all.  Weapons.  Anyway, here is the recipe:


1.5 cups flour (I use a blend of bread flour and unbleached/unbromated all-purpose flour)
1.5 teaspoons salt
1.5 cups milk
1.5 Tablespoons salad oil (not olive oil, but corn, rapeseed, or something like that)
3 medium eggs

Preheat the oven to 375 degrees (Fahrenheit).  Grease and flour 8 to 12 tins (if you have popover pans (the ones in the photo:  deep and held together with heavy wire)


this recipe will make 8 popovers.  If you are using a muffin tin, it will make a dozen smaller ones.   I confess that I use the flour and oil spray, far easier than using butter, tossing in the flour and then tossing the flour out.  Place an inch of warm water in any tins which are not being used.

Place the mile in a large mixing bowl.  Put it in the microwave for a minute to a minute-and-a-half (it should be warm, but not hot (if you have ever heated milk for a baby, a little warmer than that)).  Put the eggs in the milk (without the shells!) and whip with a wire whisk until combined.  Add the oil and salt and mix again.  Add the flour and whisk it together until almost smooth.  Do not beat it too long — it will start to activate the gluten which will ruin the popovers.

Pour the batter into the tins.  It should come up about 1/2 of the way up the popover tin or 2/3 of the way up the muffin tins.  Place in the oven and let it bake for about 20 to 30 minutes.  Take them out when the outer shell is a medium caramel brown.  They should be crispy on the outside, soft and custardy on the inside, with a large (I mean LARGE) cavity in the middle.

If you are having them for breakfast, serve with butter, honey, strawberry or blueberry preserves, or maple sugar (or combinations thereof).  If served as a dinner roll, serve them with  butter, or butter and honey.

I have had good luck whisking in a half-cup of finely shredded Asiago or Reggiano Parmesan cheese (omit the salt) and add a little more on top of the poured dough.  A good sharp yellow cheddar will also work.  I’ve also sprinkled a quarter cup of cleaned fresh wild blueberries over the poured batter — they sink in and make for a nice surprise.  If you are serving them with, say, a nice pot roast, add some finely ground herbs which complement whatever you are using on the meat.

A good popover should have a 3 to  inch puffed head and a cup-shaped bottom.  There is no polite way to eat them. Just tear them apart, pour on the toppings, and eat.



  1. You do, of course, know that popovers are not a New England dish at all? It is an Ozarks Mountains food and never appeared in New England until a restaurant on Acadia began serving them with a smarmy strawberry preserves. Your recipe won’t work, your ‘facts’ about the dish are dead wrong, so I see no reason to ever read, again, anything which you attempt to write. Get you facts right. Just once. You might enjoy it.

  2. Gourmande: Thanks for stopping by. And no, you are wrong. From Wikipedia:

    In American Food (1974), author Evan Jones writes: “Settlers from Maine who founded Portland, Oregon americanized the pudding from Yorkshire by cooking the batter in custard cups lubricated with drippings from the roasting beef (or sometimes pork); another modification was the use of garlic, and, frequently, herbs. The result is called Portland popover pudding: individual balloons of crusty meat-flavored pastry.”

    May I please see your citations?

  3. I am working on ,y eigth batch. there is no way you can make pop overs at 9000 feet in the Andes in Ecuador. Just put a new batch in the oven added 30 percent more milk and truckloads of baking powder and baking soda. what do you think

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: